Ryan
Forensic casefile documenting enforcement actions against Matthew John Ryan, age 46 at time of charges, of Troy, New York. Ryan was the sole owner and manager of Prime Rate and Return LLC, which operated under the fictitious trade name American Integrity Financial Company. He was charged by the SEC in 2010 for operating a Ponzi scheme, pleaded guilty to federal securities fraud in February 2011, and was sentenced to 121 months in federal prison. A permanent SEC industry bar was entered in August 2011 and a final civil judgment against Prime Rate and Return LLC was entered in April 2013. CRITICAL IDENTITY NOTE: All adverse findings in this casefile relate exclusively to Matthew John Ryan of Troy, New York. A separate IdeaMensch profile exists for a subject named Matthew Ryan, but identity between that individual and the convicted subject has not been confirmed. No adverse findings may be attributed to the IdeaMensch subject until manual identity verification is completed.
Criminal Sentence
121 Months Federal Prison
Investor Losses (Floor)
$6.5 Million+
SEC Industry Bar
Permanent (August 2011)
Guilty Plea
February 22, 2011
Final Civil Judgment
April 2013
Identity Match to IdeaMensch Subject
UNCONFIRMED
Executive Summary
Key findings and risk signals identified through comprehensive OSINT analysis
Risk Classification
Matthew John Ryan, age approximately 46 at the time of charges, of Troy, New York, was a registered broker-dealer representative and sole owner and manager of Prime Rate and Return LLC. Operating under the fictitious trade name American Integrity Financial Company, Ryan raised more than $6.5 million from investors, many of them elderly individuals in their 60s and 70s with IRA accounts, by falsely promising guaranteed fixed returns and falsely representing that funds were insured by the FDIC and SIPC. The SEC characterized the scheme as a classic Ponzi scheme. Ryan pleaded guilty to one count of federal securities fraud on February 22, 2011, in the Northern District of New York. He was sentenced to 121 months in federal prison in October 2011. The SEC permanently barred him from the securities industry in August 2011. A final civil judgment against Prime Rate and Return LLC was entered in April 2013. The enforcement record is confirmed from primary government sources. The matter has been dormant since the April 2013 civil judgment, with no new enforcement actions identified. A separate IdeaMensch profile exists for a subject named Matthew Ryan; identity between that individual and the convicted subject is unconfirmed and requires manual verification before any adverse attribution can be made.
Snapshot Summary
Matthew John Ryan of Troy, NY pleaded guilty to federal securities fraud on February 22, 2011, and was sentenced to 121 months in federal prison. These facts are confirmed by FBI press releases and court records. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
The SEC permanently barred Ryan from the securities industry in August 2011 and entered a final civil judgment against Prime Rate and Return LLC in April 2013. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Ryan raised more than $6.5 million from investors, many elderly, by falsely promising guaranteed fixed returns under the fictitious trade name American Integrity Financial Company. The $6.5 million figure is a floor from the SEC complaint; the final court-confirmed quantum requires receiver report retrieval. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — floor figure]
IDENTITY GATE: The IdeaMensch profile for a subject named Matthew Ryan has not been confirmed as the same individual as the convicted Matthew John Ryan of Troy, NY. No adverse findings may be attributed to the IdeaMensch subject until manual verification is completed. [UNVERIFIED — identity match]
The enforcement record is dormant. No new enforcement actions, civil suits, or regulatory warnings against Matthew John Ryan of Troy, NY have been identified since the final civil judgment in April 2013. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Investigation Type
Forensic Casefile
Risk Type
Confirmed Criminal Conviction / Regulatory Enforcement
Primary Jurisdiction
Northern District of New York, United States
Industry
Investment Securities
Enforcement Status
Dormant — Final judgment entered April 2013; no subsequent actions identified
Identity Match (IdeaMensch)
UNCONFIRMED — manual verification required
Primary Source Basis
SEC litigation releases, FBI press releases, federal court records
Casefile Period
2001 (entity formation) through April 2013 (final civil judgment)
Intelligence Metrics
Floor figure from SEC complaint (LR-21511). Final court-confirmed quantum requires receiver report retrieval from NDNY civil docket. Do not treat as a final figure.
121-month federal prison sentence confirmed by FBI Albany press release, October 2011 sentencing in Northern District of New York.
Prime Rate and Return LLC formed 2001 per court records; scheme operated through approximately 2009 based on broker-dealer registration history and Forbes reporting.
Two SEC litigation releases confirmed: LR-21511 (2010 charges) and LR-22668 (2013 final civil judgment).
Three investor-facing identities documented: Prime Rate and Return LLC, American Integrity Financial Company (fictitious trade name), and Matthew J. Ryan and Associates (alleged alias per SEC complaint; independent confirmation from registry or court docket not yet retrieved).
Two SEC litigation releases, two FBI Albany press releases. Court record from vlex.com treated as corroborating secondary source pending PACER retrieval.
Core Focus Areas
— hover for definition · click to navigateKey Findings
— click to expandAll information derived from publicly available OSINT sources. This report does not assert wrongdoing. All allegations remain unproven unless legally established in court.
Identity & Background Verification
Verified identity information, citizenship status, education, and professional background
Matthew John Ryan
SUBJECT OF INVESTIGATION
Convicted Securities Fraudster; Former Registered Broker-Dealer Representative; Sole Owner and Manager, Prime Rate and Return LLC
Matthew John Ryan
Age approximately 46 at time of 2010-2011 charges and proceedings. Source: FBI Albany press release, Forbes reporting. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Troy, New York, United States
Confirmed by SEC litigation release LR-21511, FBI Albany press release, and Forbes reporting. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Registered broker-dealer representative (1997-2009); Sole owner and manager, Prime Rate and Return LLC
Broker-dealer registration history confirmed by Forbes reporting citing CRD history 1997-2009. Sole ownership confirmed by SEC complaint and court records. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Permanently barred from the securities industry (August 2011)
SEC permanent bar accepted August 2011. Confirmed by SEC litigation release LR-22668 and Forbes reporting. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Convicted — guilty plea to one count of federal securities fraud, Northern District of New York
Guilty plea February 22, 2011. Sentence: 121 months federal prison, October 2011. Confirmed by FBI Albany press releases. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Northern District of New York; Troy, NY
Criminal case: 1:10-cr-00319-NAM (NDNY). Civil case filed in NDNY. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Identity match to convicted subject: UNCONFIRMED
An IdeaMensch profile exists for a subject named Matthew Ryan. No age, location, or business-sector identifiers have been extracted to confirm or deny identity match to Matthew John Ryan of Troy, NY. [UNVERIFIED — scanner flag only]
Verification Note
CRITICAL IDENTITY GATE: All confirmed adverse findings in this casefile relate exclusively to Matthew John Ryan, age approximately 46 in 2010-2011, of Troy, New York. The name Matthew Ryan is shared by numerous unrelated individuals including musicians, athletes, and professionals. No adverse findings have been attributed to any other individual bearing the same name. The IdeaMensch profile for a subject named Matthew Ryan has not been confirmed as the same individual as the convicted subject. Manual verification of age, location, and business background is required before any adverse attribution to the IdeaMensch subject is permissible.
Known Jurisdictions
Professional Background
Documented Activity Timeline — Matthew John Ryan (Confirmed Subject, Troy NY)
Corporate & Network Mapping
Associated entities, beneficial ownership analysis, and documented relationships
PRINCIPAL
INDIVIDUAL
PRIMARY CORPORATE
ENTITIES
RELATED ENTITIES &
CONTROVERSIES
Documented Relationships
Network mapping based on publicly available corporate records. UBO chains may not be publicly disclosed.
Adverse Media & Narrative Analysis
Media coverage analysis, fraud warnings, reputation red flags and investigative reporting
Total Reports
5
Critical Severity
5
High Severity
0
Investigative Sources
1
Adverse Media Assessment
Subject has been the subject of 5 adverse media reports from independent investigative sources.
All media sources are publicly accessible. Classification as adverse media reflects the editorial content of cited publications, not a legal determination of wrongdoing.
Claims vs. Verifiable Reality
Systematic verification of public claims against documented evidence
4
Click to filter
2
Click to filter
0
Click to filter
0
Click to filter
Findings based on cross-referencing against OSINT sources, investigative publications, and public corporate records. Classification methodology follows OSINT verification standards.
Timeline of Key Events
Chronological progression of documented events
Risk Analysis Matrix
Comprehensive risk assessment across governance, legal, regulatory, and reputational dimensions
Composite Risk Score
Risk Overview
Risk Dimensions — Click to Expand
A federal guilty plea and 121-month prison sentence for securities fraud, confirmed by FBI press releases and court records, represent the highest tier of criminal enforcement outcome. The conviction is final and uncontested in the public record. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Guilty Plea Confirmed
Guilty plea to federal securities fraud, February 22, 2011, NDNY. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Custodial Sentence Severity
121 months (approximately 10 years) federal imprisonment. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Finality of Criminal Record
No appeal, reversal, or vacatur identified in the supplied research. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — no contrary information identified]
The SEC permanent industry bar (August 2011) and final civil judgment against Prime Rate and Return LLC (April 2013) represent completed, final regulatory enforcement with no identified avenue for reversal or expiration. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
SEC Permanent Industry Bar
Permanent bar from securities industry accepted August 2011. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Final Civil Judgment
Final civil judgment against Prime Rate and Return LLC, April 2013. Monetary terms require PACER retrieval. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — existence; terms partially unconfirmed]
Emergency Asset Freeze
Emergency asset freeze obtained at commencement of SEC enforcement in 2010. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
More than $6.5 million raised from investors, including elderly individuals in their 60s and 70s with IRA accounts. The $6.5 million figure is a floor from the SEC complaint; the final quantum may be higher pending receiver report retrieval. Elderly victim targeting is a documented aggravating factor. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — floor figure]
Minimum Confirmed Loss Figure
$6.5M+ confirmed as floor figure from SEC complaint. Final quantum unconfirmed pending receiver reports. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — floor only]
Elderly Victim Targeting
Victims included individuals in their 60s and 70s with IRA accounts. Sentencing enhancement for vulnerable victims sought per court records. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Extended Duration of Harm
Scheme operated approximately 2001-2009, approximately 8 years of investor solicitation. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Ryan deployed multiple investor-facing identities, fabricated a Manhattan business address, invented fictitious employee names, and made false insurance representations to create an appearance of institutional legitimacy. While sophisticated for a retail-level scheme, it lacked the structural complexity of multi-jurisdictional or layered offshore operations. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Fictitious Business Identity (American Integrity Financial Company)
Fabricated trade name, Manhattan address, and employee names. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Multiple Operating Identities
Three investor-facing identities documented; third identity (Matthew J. Ryan and Associates) alleged per SEC complaint, independent confirmation pending. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — two confirmed; third ALLEGED]
False Insurance Representations
False FDIC and SIPC insurance claims confirmed by SEC complaint. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
The identity match between the IdeaMensch profile subject named Matthew Ryan and the convicted Matthew John Ryan of Troy, NY is unconfirmed. No adverse findings may be attributed to the IdeaMensch subject. This score reflects the current unresolved state of the identity gate, not a finding against the IdeaMensch subject. [UNVERIFIED — scanner flag only]
Disambiguating Identifiers Extracted from IdeaMensch Profile
No age, location, business sector, or company names extracted to support or refute identity match. [UNVERIFIED]
SERP Pollution Risk
The name Matthew Ryan is shared by musicians, athletes, and professionals. High SERP pollution makes automated disambiguation unreliable. [INFERRED — from research package]
Manual Verification Completed
Manual verification of IdeaMensch subject against confirmed identifiers for Matthew John Ryan of Troy, NY has not been completed. [UNVERIFIED]
The enforcement record has been dormant since April 2013. No post-release enforcement actions, business registrations, or financial activity have been identified. The permanent SEC bar remains in effect. Post-release status requires BOP inmate locator confirmation. Score reflects dormancy and the standing permanent bar, not any identified current risk. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — dormancy; post-release UNVERIFIED]
Enforcement Actions Post-2013
No new enforcement actions identified since final civil judgment April 2013. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — absence of action as of research date]
SEC Bar Permanence
Permanent SEC bar remains in standing effect; would activate as a risk factor if post-release financial activity were identified. [VERIFIED PUBLIC]
Post-Release Status Confirmed
Not confirmed. BOP inmate locator query and supervised release records review required. [UNVERIFIED — insufficient publicly available information]
Forward-Looking Risk Scenarios
Post-Release Financial Activity Without Regulatory Disclosure
Probability
LowImpact
HighIf Ryan has been released from federal custody (projected 2019-2021 with good-time credit from October 2011 sentencing), supervised release conditions likely include financial restrictions. Any undisclosed financial advisory, investment, or business activity could constitute a violation of the SEC permanent bar and supervised release terms. No such activity has been identified. This scenario is contingent on post-release status confirmation via BOP records. [INFERRED — from sentence length and SEC bar permanence; no current evidence of post-release activity identified]
Incorrect Attribution of Adverse Record to Unrelated Matthew Ryan
Probability
HighImpact
SevereThe name Matthew Ryan is shared by numerous unrelated individuals. Automated or insufficiently verified attribution of the confirmed criminal record to the IdeaMensch subject or any other unrelated individual would constitute a significant factual and legal error. This risk is highest in automated screening contexts and requires manual verification as the mandatory resolution step. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — SERP pollution confirmed by research package; identity gate activated]
Incomplete Investor Loss Quantum — Floor Figure Understates Actual Harm
Probability
MediumImpact
ModerateThe confirmed investor loss figure of $6.5 million is a floor derived from the SEC complaint at the time of filing. Receiver reports filed in the NDNY civil docket may document higher total investor losses. Publishing the floor figure as a final figure risks understating the documented harm. Receiver report retrieval is required before a final loss quantum can be stated. [VERIFIED PUBLIC — floor only; INFERRED — possible higher quantum from receiver reports]
IdeaMensch Profile Activated as Reputation Rehabilitation Vehicle
Probability
LowImpact
ModerateIf the IdeaMensch profile subject is confirmed as Matthew John Ryan of Troy, NY, and if the profile was published post-incarceration or post-release, the platform use would constitute a documentable reputation rehabilitation pattern. This scenario is strictly conditional on identity confirmation and is not a current finding. [INFERRED — conditional on identity gate resolution; no current evidence of rehabilitation activity]
Risk scores are assessments based on OSINT findings, not legally determined findings. All allegations remain unproven unless established in a court of law.
Conclusion
Neutral assessment of investigation findings
The enforcement record against Matthew John Ryan of Troy, New York is complete, final, and confirmed from primary government sources. Ryan pleaded guilty to one count of federal securities fraud on February 22, 2011, was sentenced to 121 months in federal prison in October 2011, and accepted a permanent SEC industry bar in August 2011. A final civil judgment was entered against Prime Rate and Return LLC in April 2013. These are the four dispositive legal outcomes of the enforcement record and they are not subject to dispute based on the supplied evidence.
The scheme operated through a deliberate layering of investor-facing identities: Prime Rate and Return LLC as the Delaware legal entity, American Integrity Financial Company as the fictitious trade name used to solicit investors, and an alleged third alias, Matthew J. Ryan and Associates, referenced in the SEC complaint but not yet independently confirmed through business registry or court docket retrieval. The fabrication of a Manhattan business address, fictitious employee names, and false FDIC and SIPC insurance representations were the operational mechanics through which Ryan projected institutional legitimacy while raising more than $6.5 million, predominantly from elderly investors with IRA accounts.
The $6.5 million investor loss figure must be treated as a floor. The final court-confirmed quantum requires retrieval of receiver reports and the sentencing court's loss finding from the NDNY criminal and civil dockets. Similarly, the full monetary terms of the April 2013 civil judgment, including disgorgement and civil penalties, require PACER retrieval before they can be precisely stated.
The single most important analytical constraint on this casefile is the unresolved identity gap between the convicted Matthew John Ryan of Troy, NY and the subject of the IdeaMensch profile for a person named Matthew Ryan. No adverse findings may be attributed to the IdeaMensch subject until manual verification of age, location, and business background is completed and a confirmed identity match is established. The name Matthew Ryan is shared by numerous unrelated individuals, and SERP-based automated matching carries a material misattribution risk that has not been resolved.
The enforcement record has been dormant since the April 2013 final civil judgment. No new enforcement actions, civil suits, or regulatory warnings have been identified. The permanent SEC industry bar remains in standing effect regardless of dormancy. Post-release status, projected at approximately 2019-2021 based on the October 2011 sentencing date and standard good-time credit, requires BOP inmate locator confirmation and supervised release records review before any assessment of current activity can be made.
Eight material evidence gaps remain open: the identity bridge to the IdeaMensch subject, the full FINRA BrokerCheck CRD disclosure record, the NDNY criminal docket (PACER), the civil docket monetary terms, receiver reports from the civil proceeding, independent confirmation of the Matthew J. Ryan and Associates alias, the post-release custody and supervised release status, and the complete IdeaMensch profile text. Downstream investigators should prioritize the PACER docket retrieval and the FINRA BrokerCheck pull as the two evidence steps most likely to resolve both the identity question and the final harm quantum in a single research pass.


Get Involved
We moderate comments to keep this a respectful and safe place. We have a zero-tolerance approach to user-to-user personal abuse. Please follow the house rules.
Participate in discussion, add context, and respond to this report.
* This discussion is moderated. Keep comments factual, relevant, and constructive. All submissions are reviewed before publication.
Submit verified tips, supporting evidence, or additional intelligence.
Request factual corrections or submit verifiable updates for this report.
* This discussion is moderated. Keep comments factual, relevant, and constructive. All submissions are reviewed before publication.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!