LLC
CFTC-Charged Precious Metals Boiler Room & Elderly Investor Fraud Fisher Capital LLC and its affiliated entity AMS Consulting Solutions LLC, both controlled by Alexander Spellane, are defendants in an active CFTC civil enforcement action alleging a boiler-room precious metals fraud scheme that allegedly defrauded hundreds of elderly victims of over $30 million using affinity-based sales scripts, concealed identities, and grossly inflated coin prices. The scheme is alleged to have been structured through an acquired Wyoming shell corporation and a dual-entity design intended to obscure beneficial control, with the principal having previously worked at a separately CFTC-charged predecessor operation.
This investigation synthesizes publicly available OSINT to provide a forensic overview of Fisher Capital LLC / Alexander Spellane (b. c. Unknown), Fisher Capital LLC is a Los Angeles-based precious metals retailer and its sole principal Alexander Spellane (a/k/a Alexander Overlie, Alexander Fisher) are named defendants in CFTC Case 1:23-cv-03121 (E.D.N.Y.), alleging a multimillion-dollar boiler-room fraud targeting elderly retirement investors.. Fisher holds a reported net worth of Undisclosed per Insufficient publicly available information — no public financial disclosure on record and operates Precious metals coin retailer operating via telephone boiler-room solicitations targeting elderly investors and directing SDIRA account transfers.
The investigation reveals a business model built significantly on offshore Domestic only — Wyoming (shell incorporation), California (operations), New York (federal court) structures, Affinity-based telephone solicitations allegedly exploiting Christian Conservative identity; CEO profile on fishercapitalgroup.com presenting growth narrative with no litigation disclosure (including a reported $30 million+ annual endorsement deal with Alleged victim losses per CFTC complaint and Commissioner Kristin N. Johnson statement (May 2023)), and operations in jurisdictions where activities are prohibited or locally unlicensed. Multiple concurrent civil lawsuits filed across Eastern District of New York; Los Angeles Superior Court between 2023–2026 allege Commodity fraud, fraudulent misrepresentation, false affinity-based sales scripts, concealed identities, grossly inflated coin markups, unregistered entity operations, and fraudulently induced arbitration clause.
Risk classification across all five measured dimensions is HIGH for Active Federal Enforcement, Elder Financial Fraud, Identity Concealment, Shell Company Structure, Unregistered Entity Status risk, with MODERATE ratings for Brookfield Holdings LLC UBO Gap, Criminal Referral Pipeline Status, State Parallel Proceedings risk. Significant gaps remain, including Beneficial ownership of Brookfield Holdings LLC unresolved; Wyoming SOS records not independently verified; criminal referral status unknown; precise Spellane employer chain (Chase Metals vs. Safeguard Metals) requires documentary reconciliation.
Key Findings
Table of Contents
All information derived from publicly available OSINT sources. This report does not assert wrongdoing. All allegations remain unproven unless legally established.
Subject Profile
Professional Timeline
Salesman at Chase Metals / TMTE Inc. (alleged) and/or Safeguard Metals
Per the CFTC complaint, Spellane was employed at Chase Metals/TMTE Inc. during the period relevant to the CFTC charges against that entity. Citywire independently reported Spellane as a 'closer' salesman at Safeguard Metals. Both entities operated precious metals boiler-room schemes separately charged by the CFTC. The precise employer sequence requires documentary reconciliation (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint; REPORTED — Citywire).
Founding of Fisher Capital LLC and commencement of alleged fraud scheme
The CFTC complaint alleges the fraud scheme commenced in June 2020. An original Fisher Capital LLC entity was reportedly established in Wyoming around this period and subsequently dissolved by Spellane before reconstitution via shell acquisition (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint).
Acquisition and renaming of Wyoming shell corporation
The CFTC complaint alleges Spellane acquired dormant Global Access International LLC (a Wyoming corporation originally formed in 2007) in April 2021 and renamed it Fisher Capital LLC, forming the reconstituted operating entity used to continue the alleged fraud scheme (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint).
Operation of alleged boiler-room fraud scheme via Fisher Capital LLC and AMS Consulting Solutions LLC
The CFTC complaint alleges that from June 2020 onward, Spellane directed telephone solicitation campaigns targeting elderly investors, using affinity-based scripts falsely claiming Christian Conservative values, fabricated celebrity associations, concealed identity instructions to staff, and coin markups alleged at double or triple cost, resulting in over $30 million in alleged victim losses (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint; Commissioner Johnson statement).
Named civil defendant in active CFTC enforcement action
Since April 25, 2023, Spellane and his entities are named defendants in CFTC Case 1:23-cv-03121 (E.D.N.Y.). Motion to dismiss denied July 2024. Case in active discovery as of July 2026 with settlement conference ordered July 28, 2026 before Magistrate Judge Peggy Kuo (VERIFIED PUBLIC — court docket, CourtListener).
Corporate Network & Beneficial Ownership — Fisher Capital LLC Entity Cluster
The Fisher Capital LLC corporate cluster is a tightly controlled, Spellane-centric dual-entity structure built on an acquired Wyoming dormant shell corporation. The CFTC complaint alleges the combination of Fisher Capital LLC (operating entity) and AMS Consulting Solutions LLC (alleged alter-ego) was designed to obscure beneficial control, while the Brookfield Holdings LLC corporate parent layer — disclosed only via mandatory Rule 7.1 court filing — introduces an unresolved beneficial ownership gap that has not been independently verified. The Wyoming shell acquisition and renaming sequence is cited in the CFTC complaint as evidence of deliberate pre-scheme structural engineering.
Ownership Risk: Complete UBO (Ultimate Beneficial Owner) chain beyond principal founders may remain partially obscured. Offshore entities may use nominee structures that limit transparency.
Fisher Capital LLC
2021
Wyoming (renamed from Global Access International LLC, April 2021); operations in California
AMS Consulting Solutions LLC d/b/a Fisher Capital
Unknown
Unknown — insufficient publicly available information on state of formation
Global Access International LLC
2007
Wyoming
Brookfield Holdings LLC
Unknown
Unknown — insufficient publicly available information on state of formation
Safeguard Metals LLC
Unknown
United States
Fisher Capital LLC, AMS Consulting Solutions LLC, Global Access International LLC (predecessor shell), Brookfield Holdings LLC (disclosed parent), Safeguard Metals LLC (linked prior-employer entity)
Fisher Capital LLC, AMS Consulting Solutions LLC, Global Access International LLC, and Safeguard Metals LLC all carry confirmed regulatory enforcement concerns or direct CFTC nexus
Wyoming (shell incorporation); California (operations) — all domestic
Beneficial Ownership Concern — Brookfield Holdings LLC UBO Gap
Brookfield Holdings LLC is confirmed as the disclosed corporate parent of Fisher Capital LLC via the mandatory Rule 7.1 corporate disclosure statement filed June 26, 2023 in Case 1:23-cv-03121. However, the beneficial ownership, management, and any personal relationship between Brookfield Holdings LLC and Alexander Spellane has not been independently verified in publicly available Wyoming or other state registry records. This UBO gap must be treated as an unresolved critical intelligence gap and should not be resolved by inference or assumption. No adverse claims regarding Brookfield Holdings LLC beyond its disclosed corporate parent status are warranted without independent registry verification.
Multiple Concurrent Legal Actions
Fisher Capital LLC, AMS Consulting Solutions LLC, and Alexander Spellane face active civil enforcement proceedings in two separate courts: a primary CFTC civil enforcement action in the Eastern District of New York (Case 1:23-cv-03121, filed April 2023) that survived a Rule 9(b) motion to dismiss in July 2024 and is approaching a court-ordered settlement conference in July 2026; and a separate civil plaintiff action in Los Angeles Superior Court in which Fisher Capital's motion to compel arbitration was denied in February 2024 on unconscionability and fraudulent-inducement grounds. No confirmed criminal proceedings are on record as of July 2026.
Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC)
Fisher Capital LLC; AMS Consulting Solutions LLC d/b/a Fisher Capital; Alexander Spellane a/k/a Alexander Overlie a/k/a Alexander Fisher
Disgorgement of ill-gotten gains, restitution to victims, civil monetary penalties, permanent trading and registration ban, and injunctive relief — aggregate loss figure alleged at $30 million+
- —Commodity fraud and fraudulent misrepresentation in connection with precious metals transactions
- —Operation of a boiler-room telephone solicitation scheme targeting elderly investors using affinity-based scripts falsely claiming Christian Conservative values and fabricated celebrity associations
- —Sale of coins at markups alleged to be double or triple cost without disclosure
- —Concealment of principal identity through use of aliases (Alexander Overlie, Alexander Fisher) and instructions to staff to withhold true identities
- —Acquisition of dormant Wyoming shell corporation (Global Access International LLC) and renaming to Fisher Capital LLC as alleged entity engineering
- —Operation of alter-ego entity AMS Consulting Solutions LLC to obscure beneficial control
- —Solicitation and direction of SDIRA account transfers from elderly victims
- —Unregistered entity operations
CFTC complaint filed April 25, 2023. Judge Carol Bagley Amon denied defendants' motion to dismiss July 2024, ruling fraud claims sufficiently pleaded under Rule 9(b). Discovery closes July 8, 2026. Settlement statements due July 17, 2026. Settlement conference before Magistrate Judge Peggy Kuo scheduled July 28, 2026. Pretrial order deadline August 5, 2026 if no dispositive motions. FINRA and Mississippi Secretary of State cooperation referenced in complaint. Safeguard Metals $51M+ final judgment (November 2025) provides enforcement penalty benchmark (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC press release, complaint PDF, court docket via CourtListener).
Source: CFTC Press Release 8694-23; CFTC Complaint PDF (enffishercapitalcomplaint042535); CourtListener Docket 67264046
4+ Prohibited Markets
Operating across 0 jurisdictions with comprehensive bans and 4 jurisdictions requiring local licenses not held. Primary regulatory cover derives from an offshore license — a jurisdiction criticized for weak oversight that provides no meaningful enforcement beyond its borders.
Multiple sources allege active encouragement of users in prohibited jurisdictions to use VPNs to bypass geographic restrictions, despite public compliance statements.
Domestic Regulatory Arbitrage Pattern
Fisher Capital LLC's entity structure exploits domestic permissive jurisdictions rather than offshore structures: Wyoming's low-disclosure incorporation environment was used for shell acquisition and renaming, California's large market provided the victim base and operational footprint, and the dual-entity structure (Fisher Capital LLC + AMS Consulting Solutions LLC) was allegedly designed to obscure beneficial control from retail investors, SDIRA custodians, and regulators. The CFTC complaint's reference to FINRA and Mississippi SOS cooperation suggests the scheme's telephone solicitations crossed multiple state regulatory boundaries, triggering a multi-authority response that has not yet resulted in parallel state enforcement orders as of July 2026.
Wyoming Shell Corporation Acquisition and Renaming
HIGHThe CFTC complaint alleges Spellane dissolved the original Fisher Capital LLC and acquired a dormant Wyoming shell corporation (Global Access International LLC, incorporated 2007) in 2021, renaming it Fisher Capital LLC. Wyoming's permissive, low-disclosure incorporation environment and the deliberate use of a pre-existing dormant shell with a changed name is cited as evidence of intentional entity engineering to obscure continuity and control of the alleged scheme (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint).
Source: CFTC Complaint PDF — enffishercapitalcomplaint042535
Dual Alter-Ego Entity Structure Obscuring Beneficial Control
HIGHThe CFTC complaint characterizes AMS Consulting Solutions LLC as an alter-ego entity of Fisher Capital LLC, with both 100% owned by Spellane, creating a dual-entity operational structure alleged to obscure who controls the scheme and facilitate regulatory evasion. The Rule 7.1 disclosure of a third-tier corporate parent (Brookfield Holdings LLC) adds an additional unresolved opacity layer (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint, Rule 7.1 filing).
Source: CFTC Complaint; CourtListener Docket 67264046
Principal Identity Concealment via Multiple Aliases
HIGHThe CFTC complaint alleges Spellane used aliases 'Alexander Overlie' and 'Alexander Fisher' as operational scheme elements, including instructions to staff to withhold true identities from customers and SDIRA custodians. This is alleged not as incidental name variation but as a deliberate fraud-facilitation mechanism documented across multiple scheme interactions (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint; Commissioner Johnson statement).
Source: CFTC Complaint; CFTC Commissioner Johnson Statement (May 23, 2023)
Recidivist Prior-Employer Link to CFTC-Charged Predecessor Scheme
HIGHSpellane is alleged in the CFTC complaint to have been employed at Chase Metals/TMTE Inc. during the period of that entity's own CFTC enforcement proceedings. Citywire independently reported Spellane as a 'closer' at Safeguard Metals — also separately CFTC-charged — before founding Fisher Capital. The Safeguard Metals $51M+ final judgment (November 2025) confirms the predecessor scheme was fully adjudicated at maximum penalties (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint; CFTC Press Release 9139-25; REPORTED — Citywire).
Source: CFTC Complaint; CFTC Press Release 9139-25; Citywire
Operation of Promotional Website Without Litigation Disclosure During Active Federal Enforcement
MODERATEFisher Capital's website (fishercapitalgroup.com) continued to publish a CEO profile page presenting employee growth from 20 to 50+ and ambitions to become 'the nation's number one precious metal retailer' with no disclosure of the active federal CFTC enforcement action filed April 2023 and ongoing through July 2026. This creates a documented public image contradiction between promotional claims and the federal enforcement record (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint and docket; WEAK — subject-controlled website fishercapitalgroup.com).
Source: fishercapitalgroup.com CEO profile; CFTC Press Release 8694-23
Unresolved Brookfield Holdings LLC Beneficial Ownership Gap
MODERATEBrookfield Holdings LLC is confirmed as the disclosed corporate parent of Fisher Capital LLC via Rule 7.1 filing, but its beneficial ownership, control structure, and any relationship to Alexander Spellane personally is unverified in publicly available sources. The gap may represent a further opacity layer in the entity structure or may reflect an unrelated holding arrangement — INSUFFICIENT PUBLICLY AVAILABLE INFORMATION to resolve without independent Wyoming or other state registry verification (VERIFIED PUBLIC — Rule 7.1 disclosure; UBO status: unverified).
Source: CourtListener Docket 67264046 — Rule 7.1 Corporate Disclosure Statement (June 26, 2023)
Evidence-Based Verification
Each claim has been assessed against available primary sources. Click any row to expand detailed evidence, methodology, and source citations. Status badges reflect independent verification quality.
Chronological Record
The following chronology documents the complete regulatory and judicial timeline of the Fisher Capital LLC investigation from the entity's alleged founding in June 2020 through the court-ordered settlement conference scheduled for July 28, 2026. All dates are sourced from primary government documents, the federal court docket, and corroborating media reporting. Evidence class labels are applied at each entry.
Global Access International LLC Incorporated in Wyoming
The dormant Wyoming shell corporation Global Access International LLC was originally incorporated in 2007, per the CFTC complaint. It remained dormant until its acquisition by Spellane in 2021 and subsequent renaming to Fisher Capital LLC. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint.
Fisher Capital LLC Founded; Alleged Fraud Scheme Commences
The CFTC complaint alleges the fraud scheme began in June 2020. An original Fisher Capital LLC entity was reportedly established in Wyoming around this period. Spellane is alleged to have departed Chase Metals/TMTE Inc. (and/or Safeguard Metals per Citywire) before or around this period. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint; REPORTED — Citywire.
Wyoming Shell Acquisition: Global Access International LLC Renamed Fisher Capital LLC
Per the CFTC complaint, Spellane acquired dormant Global Access International LLC (Wyoming, incorporated 2007) in April 2021 and renamed it Fisher Capital LLC, reconstituting the operating entity through a pre-existing shell. The CFTC characterizes this as a deliberate structural engineering step. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC complaint.
CFTC Files Civil Enforcement Action — Case 1:23-cv-03121 (E.D.N.Y.)
The Commodity Futures Trading Commission filed a civil enforcement action on April 25, 2023 in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of New York against Fisher Capital LLC, AMS Consulting Solutions LLC d/b/a Fisher Capital, and Alexander Spellane, alleging multimillion-dollar precious metals fraud targeting elderly investors resulting in over $30 million in alleged losses. FINRA and Mississippi SOS cooperation referenced. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC Press Release 8694-23; CFTC complaint PDF.
CFTC Commissioner Kristin N. Johnson Issues Formal Statement Supporting Enforcement Action
Commissioner Johnson issued a formal statement confirming the complaint alleges Spellane exploited Christian Conservative affinity identity through scripted false claims, charged victims at prices 'double or even triple' cost, and that $30M+ in victim losses are documented. CFTC Director McGinley described defendants as 'wolves in sheep's clothing.' Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — Commissioner Johnson Statement; CFTC Press Release 8694-23.
Brookfield Holdings LLC Disclosed as Corporate Parent via Rule 7.1 Filing
Defendants filed a Rule 7.1 corporate disclosure statement in Case 1:23-cv-03121 on June 26, 2023, identifying Brookfield Holdings LLC as the corporate parent of Fisher Capital LLC. Beneficial ownership of Brookfield Holdings LLC and any relationship to Spellane personally remains unverified in publicly available sources — UBO gap. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — court docket, CourtListener.
Los Angeles Superior Court Denies Fisher Capital Arbitration Motion
Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Michael Whitaker denied Fisher Capital LLC's motion to compel arbitration in a separate civil plaintiff action, finding the arbitration clause void as fraudulently induced and unconscionable. Reported by attorney Thomas Mauriello, who represented the opposing party. Full order text and case number not confirmed in publicly available sources. Evidence class: REPORTED — Mauriello Law firm post (Tier 3).
Judge Carol Bagley Amon Denies Defendants' Motion to Dismiss — Case Enters Discovery
Judge Carol Bagley Amon of the Eastern District of New York denied defendants' motion to dismiss the CFTC complaint, ruling the fraud claims were sufficiently pleaded under Rule 9(b). The case formally entered the discovery phase. This ruling confirms the allegations clear the minimum pleading threshold but does not constitute a finding of liability. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — court docket, CourtListener.
Safeguard Metals LLC $51M+ Final Judgment — Enforcement Precedent Established
The CFTC obtained a final judgment of over $51 million against Safeguard Metals LLC (Jeffrey Ikahn) for a precious metals boiler-room scheme identical in structure to the Fisher Capital allegations. Citywire reported Spellane worked at Safeguard Metals before founding Fisher Capital. This judgment establishes the primary enforcement penalty benchmark for the Fisher Capital case. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC Press Release 9139-25; REPORTED — Citywire (Spellane-Safeguard link).
Federal Court Orders Confidential Settlement Statements — Case 1:23-cv-03121
The Eastern District of New York court ordered parties in CFTC v. Fisher Capital LLC to submit confidential settlement statements, confirming the litigation remained active and was entering a resolution phase as of late 2025. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — court docket, CourtListener.
Discovery Closes July 8, 2026; Settlement Statements Due July 17, 2026
All discovery in Case 1:23-cv-03121 closes July 8, 2026. Confidential settlement statements are due to be submitted by July 17, 2026. Pretrial order deadline set for August 5, 2026 if no dispositive motions are filed. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — court docket, CourtListener.
Settlement Conference Scheduled — July 28, 2026 Before Magistrate Judge Peggy Kuo (E.D.N.Y.)
A court-ordered settlement conference in CFTC v. Fisher Capital LLC (Case 1:23-cv-03121) is scheduled for July 28, 2026 before Magistrate Judge Peggy Kuo in the Eastern District of New York. This is the most significant immediate procedural milestone and may result in a consent order, ongoing negotiations, or escalation to trial. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC — court docket, CourtListener.
Social Media Presence
Fisher Capital LLC maintains a live commercial website at fishercapitalgroup.com presenting promotional content including a CEO profile for Alexander Spellane. No confirmed active social media accounts for Fisher Capital LLC or Alexander Spellane have been independently identified in publicly available sources as of July 2026. The website's continued operation with investor-facing promotional content and no litigation disclosure during active federal enforcement proceedings is the primary digital intelligence finding of this investigation.
Live commercial website as of the investigation period. Hosts a CEO profile page for Alexander Spellane claiming growth from 20 to 50+ employees and ambition to become 'the nation's number one precious metal retailer.' No disclosure of CFTC Case 1:23-cv-03121 or any litigation. Evidence class: WEAK (subject-controlled content). Significant as a documented public image contradiction against the active federal enforcement record.
Fisher Capital LLC issued an emailed denial to Reuters at the time of CFTC filing (April 2023) stating it 'sincerely disagrees with the allegations' and 'never targeted any specific demographic.' No subsequent verified public statements from Fisher Capital or Spellane have been identified. Denial documented via Intelligenceline report referencing the Reuters contact. Evidence class: REPORTED (Tier 3 — Intelligenceline citation of Reuters contact).
Fisher Capital LLC, AMS Consulting Solutions LLC, and Alexander Spellane are listed as defendants in active CFTC civil enforcement proceedings. The CFTC database is the authoritative Tier 1 primary government source for regulatory enforcement status. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC.
Full docket for CFTC v. Fisher Capital LLC available via CourtListener. Confirms all key procedural milestones including complaint filing, Rule 7.1 disclosure, motion to dismiss denial, discovery schedule, and July 28, 2026 settlement conference. Evidence class: VERIFIED PUBLIC (Tier 1 judicial record).
The Wayback Machine harvest of fishercapitalgroup.com has not been independently completed for this investigation. The CEO profile page content (employee growth claims, 'nation's number one' retailer ambition) is documented from the live site at the time of investigation. Whether earlier or later archived versions exist with materially different claims, or with any version of litigation disclosure added post-April 2023, is INSUFFICIENT PUBLICLY AVAILABLE INFORMATION. A systematic Wayback Machine harvest comparing snapshots before and after the April 2023 CFTC filing is a recommended follow-on investigative step to establish the precise timeline of the public image contradiction and confirm whether the site was modified in response to enforcement.
Community Intelligence
No confirmed consumer forum, Reddit, social media community, or victim advocacy group discussions specifically about Fisher Capital LLC or Alexander Spellane have been identified in publicly available sources sufficient for publication-grade citation as of July 2026. The Intelligenceline third-party risk report references FINRA and Mississippi SOS cooperation and records Fisher Capital's denial — this is the closest available third-party aggregation of community-level intelligence. Victim accounts referenced in the CFTC complaint are anonymized and not available for direct community-source characterization.
CFTC Complaint Victim Characterizations (Anonymized)
- —The CFTC complaint alleges hundreds of elderly investors were targeted via telephone solicitation campaigns using affinity-based scripts falsely claiming Christian Conservative values and fabricated associations with conservative media personalities.
- —Victims were allegedly instructed to transfer retirement savings via SDIRA accounts into purchases of precious metals coins sold at markups alleged to be double or triple cost, without disclosure of the true markup or Spellane's true identity.
- —Commissioner Johnson's statement confirms allegations that victims were persuaded by scripts exploiting religious and political identity — a form of affinity fraud specifically targeting trust-based community connections.
Source: CFTC Complaint PDF — enffishercapitalcomplaint042535 (Tier 1 primary government document)
Narrative Shifts & PR Events
The CFTC's public announcement of the enforcement action (Press Release 8694-23) included a direct statement from Division of Enforcement Director Ian McGinley characterizing Fisher Capital's principals as 'wolves in sheep's clothing' exploiting elderly investors' retirement savings. The release was widely disseminated and triggered Fisher Capital's emailed denial to Reuters. This is the primary public narrative entry point for the enforcement story (VERIFIED PUBLIC — CFTC Press Release 8694-23).
CFTC Commissioner Kristin N. Johnson issued a formal public statement on May 23, 2023 specifically supporting the Fisher Capital enforcement action and detailing the affinity-fraud mechanism alleged in the complaint — including the Christian Conservative identity script, the fabricated celebrity associations, and the double-or-triple cost markup allegation. The statement elevated the case's public and regulatory salience beyond a routine enforcement filing (VERIFIED PUBLIC — Commissioner Johnson Statement).
Citywire's investigative report independently corroborated Spellane as a 'closer' salesman at Safeguard Metals before founding Fisher Capital, and confirmed Fisher Capital was established after Spellane's departure from Safeguard shortly before CFTC and SEC complaints against Safeguard were filed. This media corroboration strengthens the alleged recidivist pattern but requires attribution as REPORTED evidence pending documentary verification (REPORTED — Citywire, Tier 2 media corroboration).
Brookfield Holdings LLC Beneficial Ownership (CRITICAL)
Critical GapBrookfield Holdings LLC is confirmed as the disclosed corporate parent of Fisher Capital LLC via the Rule 7.1 corporate disclosure statement filed June 26, 2023. However, the beneficial ownership, management structure, state of formation, and any personal relationship between Brookfield Holdings LLC and Alexander Spellane has not been independently verified in any publicly available registry records. This gap may represent an additional control layer obscuring beneficial ownership or may reflect an unrelated holding arrangement — INSUFFICIENT PUBLICLY AVAILABLE INFORMATION to resolve without Wyoming or other state SOS registry verification. This is the single most significant unresolved structural intelligence gap in the investigation.
Wyoming Secretary of State Records — Global Access International LLC and Brookfield Holdings LLC
Critical GapThe CFTC complaint documents the acquisition and renaming of Global Access International LLC (Wyoming, 2007) to Fisher Capital LLC in April 2021. Independent Wyoming SOS registry verification of this sequence — including formation date, registered agent identity, amendment records, member/manager disclosures, and any Spellane or alias-name associations — has not been completed for this investigation. Similarly, Wyoming or other state SOS records for Brookfield Holdings LLC have not been independently retrieved. These registry records are necessary to confirm the shell acquisition sequence, identify any nominee arrangements, and resolve the Brookfield Holdings LLC UBO gap.
Criminal Referral and Parallel Criminal Proceedings Status
Critical GapThe CFTC complaint references FINRA and Mississippi SOS cooperation, which may indicate a multi-authority investigative pipeline with potential criminal referral implications. No parallel DOJ, FBI, or state prosecutor criminal indictment or referral involving Fisher Capital LLC or Alexander Spellane has been identified in publicly available sources as of July 2026. The absence of confirmed criminal proceedings is an affirmative finding that must be disclosed, but the question of whether a criminal referral exists in a non-public investigative stage remains an unresolved intelligence gap. This gap requires active monitoring of DOJ press releases, PACER, and state prosecutor records.
Precise Spellane Prior-Employer Chain — Chase Metals/TMTE Inc. vs. Safeguard Metals
Critical GapThe CFTC complaint references Chase Metals/TMTE Inc. as Spellane's prior employer during the relevant charge period. Citywire independently reported Spellane as a 'closer' at Safeguard Metals before founding Fisher Capital. These are potentially distinct legal entities within the same boiler-room ecosystem, or may share corporate relationships not confirmed in public records. The precise employer sequence — whether Spellane worked at TMTE Inc./Chase Metals, Safeguard Metals, or both, and in what order — requires documentary reconciliation from employment records, corporate registration data, or additional complaint filings before the recidivist employer chain can be stated with full precision.
Los Angeles Superior Court Case Number and Full Order Text — Arbitration Motion Denial
Moderate GapThe denial of Fisher Capital's motion to compel arbitration by Judge Michael Whitaker (Los Angeles Superior Court, February 2024) is reported by the Mauriello Law firm, which represented the opposing party. The full case number, complete order text, plaintiff identity, and precise grounds of the unconscionability and fraudulent-inducement findings are not confirmed in publicly available court records identified for this investigation. Retrieval of the full court order from the Los Angeles Superior Court register is a required next step to elevate this finding from REPORTED (Tier 3) to VERIFIED PUBLIC (Tier 1).
Post-July 17, 2026 Settlement or Consent Order Outcome
Moderate GapAs of the investigation date, confidential settlement statements are due July 17, 2026 and a settlement conference is ordered for July 28, 2026 before Magistrate Judge Peggy Kuo (E.D.N.Y.). The outcome of this conference — whether a consent order, ongoing negotiations, trial preparation, or default judgment — is unknown and will materially change the case status, penalty quantum, and remediation picture. This gap requires monitoring of PACER and CFTC press releases immediately following the July 28, 2026 conference. Publication-ready update language should be prepared for all three resolution scenarios: consent order, continued litigation, or default judgment.
AMS Consulting Solutions LLC State of Formation and Registration Records
Moderate GapAMS Consulting Solutions LLC is identified as a co-defendant and alleged alter-ego entity 100% owned by Spellane, but the state of formation, registered agent, formation date, and any state-level registration or licensing records for AMS Consulting Solutions LLC have not been independently verified in publicly available sources for this investigation. These records are necessary to fully map the dual-entity structure and confirm whether AMS Consulting Solutions LLC was formed before or after the commencement of the alleged fraud scheme — a chronology that would be material to the alter-ego allegation.
Investigative Conclusion: Fisher Capital LLC
Fisher Capital LLC, AMS Consulting Solutions LLC, and their sole alleged principal Alexander Spellane (a/k/a Alexander Overlie, Alexander Fisher) present one of the most fully documented active federal consumer fraud enforcement cases in the U.S. precious metals sector. The primary finding of this investigation is that the CFTC civil enforcement action (Case 1:23-cv-03121, E.D.N.Y., filed April 25, 2023) has survived a Rule 9(b) motion to dismiss, entered active discovery, and is now approaching a court-ordered settlement conference before Magistrate Judge Peggy Kuo on July 28, 2026 — making this a live, imminently resolving federal enforcement story. The alleged scheme — a telephone boiler-room targeting elderly investors with affinity-fraud scripting, identity concealment, and coin markups of double or triple cost — resulted in alleged losses exceeding $30 million across hundreds of victims, a figure confirmed by a senior federal official (Commissioner Johnson). The Safeguard Metals $51 million+ final judgment (November 2025) for an identical predecessor scheme in which Spellane is reported to have worked provides the most directly relevant penalty benchmark for the Fisher Capital case.
The corporate structure underlying the alleged scheme reflects a pattern of deliberate opacity: the primary operating entity was reconstituted through the acquisition and renaming of a dormant Wyoming shell corporation (Global Access International LLC), an alter-ego entity (AMS Consulting Solutions LLC) was operated in parallel, and the principal used multiple documented aliases as alleged operational scheme elements per the CFTC complaint. An additional, unresolved beneficial ownership gap exists in the form of Brookfield Holdings LLC — disclosed as corporate parent via mandatory Rule 7.1 court filing, but with no independently verified beneficial ownership chain connecting it to Spellane or any other identified party. The subject's promotional website continues to operate with growth-narrative content and no litigation disclosure — a documentable public image contradiction against the active federal enforcement record.
For journalists, regulators, SDIRA custodians, and counterparty risk teams: the July 28, 2026 settlement conference is the immediate monitoring priority. Three resolution scenarios are plausible: (1) a consent order with penalties benchmarked against the Safeguard Metals $51M+ precedent, representing the most likely documented outcome; (2) continued litigation leading to a trial and contested judgment; or (3) default judgment if defendants fail to participate in settlement proceedings. Any resolution will require prompt update of this dossier to reflect the penalty quantum, disgorgement and restitution orders, any injunctive relief limiting Spellane's future operations, and the status of the FINRA-Mississippi SOS regulatory pipeline. The six identified intelligence gaps — particularly the Brookfield Holdings LLC UBO question, the precise Spellane prior-employer chain, and the criminal referral status — require active monitoring and independent verification before publication of the final resolved-case record.
Methodology: This investigation was conducted using the Regulatory/Enforcement Dominant feeder methodology anchored to the CFTC civil complaint (Case 1:23-cv-03121, E.D.N.Y.) as the primary analytical document, corroborated by the federal court docket (CourtListener), CFTC press releases, and the formal statement of Commissioner Kristin N. Johnson. Media corroboration was drawn from Citywire's investigative report on the broader precious metals regulatory ecosystem. Third-party risk intelligence was referenced from the Intelligenceline report and the Mauriello Law firm reporting on the LA Superior Court arbitration motion denial. Subject-controlled content from fishercapitalgroup.com was classified as a weak evidence source and treated as promotional self-description rather than verified fact. All claims are evidence-class labeled. No anonymous tip material has been converted to verified claims. Six critical intelligence gaps have been identified and explicitly disclosed. No criminal framing has been used — all findings relate to the active civil enforcement record. The investigation does not constitute a finding of liability and all alleged conduct is attributed to the CFTC complaint or corroborating primary sources.
All information derived from publicly available OSINT sources. This report does not assert wrongdoing. All allegations remain unproven unless legally established.
CFTC Press Release 8694-23 — Fisher Capital LLC Enforcement Action (April 2023)
Primary CFTC press release confirming filing of Case 1:23-cv-03121, characterizing Fisher Capital as boiler room, confirming FINRA and Mississippi SOS cooperation, and quoting Director McGinley
CFTC Civil Complaint — Fisher Capital LLC (Case 1:23-cv-03121)
Primary complaint document — source for all scheme mechanics, shell acquisition sequence, alias use allegations, AMS alter-ego characterization, and Chase Metals/TMTE Inc. prior employer reference
CFTC Commissioner Kristin N. Johnson Statement — May 23, 2023
Senior official confirmation of affinity-fraud script mechanism, Christian Conservative identity exploitation, double-or-triple cost markup, and $30M+ victim losses
CFTC Press Release 9139-25 — Safeguard Metals Final Judgment (November 2025)
Confirms $51M+ final judgment against Safeguard Metals LLC/Jeffrey Ikahn — primary enforcement precedent and penalty benchmark for Fisher Capital case


Get Involved
We moderate comments to keep this a respectful and safe place. We have a zero-tolerance approach to user-to-user personal abuse. Please follow the house rules.
Participate in discussion, add context, and respond to this report.
* This discussion is moderated. Keep comments factual, relevant, and constructive. All submissions are reviewed before publication.
Submit verified tips, supporting evidence, or additional intelligence.
Request factual corrections or submit verifiable updates for this report.
* This discussion is moderated. Keep comments factual, relevant, and constructive. All submissions are reviewed before publication.
No comments yet. Be the first to comment!